21 Votes in Poll
I only own the Reaper, but I prefer it over Posiedon's Trident and Power Fists.
I only have the Power Fists, and I like 'em. But I'm really looking forward to getting the Reaper!
I've got the Champion Peacemaker, so Excally is totally meh, redundant. ;-)
I'll be glad to get the rest, but the Fists and the Reaper are those that I really want and will probably use.